The Mercury Prize has received its fair share of criticism throughout the years. Years when the shortlist has been criticised for its focus on big-name stars like Arctic Monkeys, David Bowie, Foals and Jake Bugg in 2013, though this argument seems to have been turned on its head for 2014. Apart from Brit-rock royalty Damon Albarn and genre-jumping Londoners Bombay Bicycle Club, the list is pretty bereft of big names. On the one hand you might be tempted to argue that quality should rise to the surface, though, on the other side of the argument, you can say that it is more important to nurture the talent of young, up-and-coming artists like FKA Twigs or East India Youth.
Bombay Bicycle Club – So Long, See You Tomorrow:
Probably the best known name on the list apart from Damon Albarn, it’s kind of surprising that BBC hadn’t been nominated for one of their three previous albums, all of which are very different. It seems like BBC has taken a world-music route on this album, using Indian infused music and synthesizers to create a really exultant album
When I look back at some of the nominees from the early nineties I’m at a loss to judge whether the correct winner was picked that year or if there was some outstanding outsider who got fucked by the mainstream. This might sound like a bad thing but it’s not really. I get to listen to what was critically acclaimed in England in 1994 or 1997, during the Brit Pop boom, or nearing the end of the Slacker/Madchester days, you can see the effect bands like Oasis and Radiohead have made on certain generations as you hear imitations come through in the early 2000’s. The Mercury Prize may be a prestigious award for certain artists, but its most important function is to act like a Time Capsule or archive, documenting the musical tastes of a generation for perpetuity.
Royal Blood – Royal Blood:
It wasn’t a huge year for Blues-Rock, with artists like Mac DeMarco and Real Estate leaving The Black Keys and Jack White in the background as their drawling-sunburst-slacker-rock gained traction. Royal Blood, however, managed to gain considerable attention for their debut and with plenty of similarities to one-time British Rock Royalty Muse, they look set to enjoy further acclaim. Probably one of the favourites.
It’s really odd to look back at the list in 1994 and see Take That’s name alongside Blur and Paul Weller. Did the Mercury Panel just decide to go with the popular acts that year or were Take That genuinely talented at one point in time? Who can tell? Even more shocking is the inclusion of The Spice Girls in 1997. I may sometimes look back on The Spice Girls’ music with disdain but it’s undoubtable that they left their mark on my childhood as I was forced to listen to their songs, living with a teenage sister while they were still together. In that sense it seems right to say that popular bands, even if I might dislike their music, must be remembered too. They must go down as the promising acts of the year even if just to communicate a sense of the time, a way of describing a Zeitgeist almost.
Polar Bear – In Each and Every One:
It’s tempting to designate Polar Bear as the outsider, included as the obligatory Jazz inclusion of the year, but, alas, GoGo Penguin have also gotten the nod, along with spoken-word artist Kate Tempest, making it a year for diversity. Perhaps a little too distanced from lighter acts on the list, like Bombay Bicycle Club and East India Youth, but there shouldn’t be any doubts about their inclusion. Creating a concatenation of Jazz, Jazz Fusion and Electronica and sounding like Miles Davis meets Burial, Polar Bear should be listened to in their own right and not just because they are on this list.
1992, the awards’ first year, saw Simply Red nominated for Stars. I want to laugh, Simply Red used to be my mother’s favourite singer. We’d have to listen to his music, along with The Eagles and multiple X-factor winners, in the car as we drove my sister to Irish Dancing competitions. So much so that I imagine the inside of the car whenever I hear any of his songs.
Nick Mulvey – First Mind:
Mulvey was nominated for the prize with former band Portico Quartet in 2008. He played the Hang (similar to a steelpan but with more resonance/droning, like a helmholtz resonator.) First Mind is Mulvey’s first solo studio album, following on from the release of two Eps; The Trellis and Fever to the Form. Mulvey’s solo work is in a similar vein to the pleasing, stripped-back folk of previous nominees like Villagers and Ben Howard.
Cornership, the genius’ who gave ‘Brimful of Asha’ to the world, were nominated in 1998 for When I Was Born for the 7th Time. Coldplay got the nod in 2000 when their debut album, Parachutes, came out. Ms Dynamite won the award in 2002, a year with a pretty urban-heavy shortlist, showing the explosion of Garage and R&B music at the time.
Young Fathers – Dead:
Young fathers are a multicultural hip/hop group from Scotland, they’re one of the older groups on the list having formed in 2008. Dead is their first album, however, and it’s a great showcase of what Young Fathers can do; make danceable music that does not necessarily always sound upbeat as the band do experiments with atmospherics.
Klaxons, who recently announced that they will be splitting up after their next tour, won in 2007 for their debut Myths of the Near Future which seemed like the definitive album of the Nu-Rave/Skins era that seems so long ago now. Speech Debelle won it two years later for her forthright and principled type of rap, in the form of the Meshell Ndegeocelle. Speech winning was probably the biggest shock in recent history, unless you count James Blake’s triumph over David Bowie and Arctic Monkeys last year.
Kate Tempest – Everybody Down:
Originally a spoken word artist, Kate Tempest sounds perfectly comfortable as she raps on Everybody Down, channelling a fair amount attitude while doing so. She helps the listener remember what is great about rap; it’s realistic tone. She doesn’t shirk away or overly emphasize the aphorisms that she seems to stumble across rather than seek. Really good but unlikely to win.
There were a few years when The Mercury Prize went completely mainstream, about the time when Q Magazine was really big. In 2004 a pretty drastic shift in tastes occurred. I can only think that this must have been planned and talked about, there could be no other reason for such a large overhaul, unless the whole panel was replaced in just one year. Keane, Jamelia, Joss Stone and The Zutons were nominated in 2004. If you want to think of the modern equivalent maybe try Kodaline, Rita Ora, Jessie J and Ed Sheeran. How weird would that be? To see FKA Twigs alongside Kodaline on the night would be ludicrous wouldn’t it? That’s because there has been another shift in tastes. It’s obvious that the public has pressured the panel to focus their attention farther afield than the fringes of Pop and Rock Music. With two Jazz albums, one soul album, a spoken word album, a blues album amongst others, this year’s selection caters for a wide variety of tastes. Priorities seem to have changed as the growth of home-grown and independently disseminated music has coincided with a boom in internet consumption, which also provides a lot more access to music for fans.
Jungle – Jungle:
Jungle seem to be everybody’s favourite soul collective at the minute. Their success reminds me of that enjoyed by Rudimental not so long ago, with songs full of energy and movement. They’ve also been nominated for BBC’s Sound of 2014 prize. Formed by friends Tom McFarland and Josh Lloyd Watson last year and have been going from strength to strength since. Probably unlikely to win but definitely a band to look out for in the future.
It’s a good time for the Mercury Prize, it seems, they are no longer trying to provide what they think people want, It seems that there is no doubt as to what music fans want and it relies on an ideal rather than a specific genre; diversity. With continued positive attitudes music may continue to progress and grow more complicated and elaborate, with twists and turns of a variety of different cultures or sounds thrown together.
GoGo Penguin – v2.0:
The second jazz band on the list, GoGo Penguin combine Jazz and Electronica to create a kind of comfortable urbaneness. Their music reminds me of Destroyer or Antlers, though with more pace and deviations. V2.0 is the band’s second album after 2012’s Fanfares. Another band unlikely to win but still really great at creating an interesting ambience.
Does this mean that there should be a limit to the amount that a band can win or be nominated? Maybe something similar to the Nobel Prize, though without the extensive waits. Last year Arctic Monkeys were heavily tipped to become the second act to win the award twice, after PJ Harvey. Five other bands were being nominated for the second time in 2013. Foals with Holy Fire, Laura Marling with Once I Was an Eagle, David Bowie with The Next Day, Villagers with Awayland and eventual winner James Blake with Overgrown. Debuting bands who may have fared better from the attention might have been The 1975 with their eponymous debut or King Krule who released 6 Feet Beneath The Moon. It’s important to give recognition to great artists who encompass generations and different genres, but beyond reacting to a new trend or creating one themselves it might be of more benefit to leave names like Radiohead and Pj Harvey off the list, though they produce brilliance. Awards are not really for prestige, deep down, they are more like historical documents that record the attitudes of a country. I don’t want to be a downer but Award lists have real social importance and, in this sense, it is important to care and to argue for a better system.
FKA Twigs – LP1:
FKA Twigs has been touted as the odds on favourite to win the prize this year. This is a pretty deceptive view of how these things go, however. There’s no doubt that FKA Twigs makes fantastically odd and alien music, similar to Canadian Jane-of-all-trades Grimes, but I feel that she may be at the top of the list because of the media attention her relationship with Robert Pattinson is getting. Still a favourite, but don’t be surprised if she doesn’t win.
But, at the same time, it’s really difficult to tell who will win the prize this year. This is exciting, maybe FKA Twigs will emulate James Blake and produce an album as brilliant as Overgrown, East Indie Youth could go down the same road, Nick Mulvey sounds great and has the potential to overshadow his folksy predecessors, Bombay Bicycle Cub are quickly becoming one of the most exciting bands around as they continue to change directions drastically and Damon Albarn shows no sign of slowing down, which is good considering the impending comeback of Gorillaz.
East India Youth – Total Strife Forever:
Using bedroom ambience and lush production, East India Youth reminds me of an extroverted Balam Acab. Relatively new to the music scene, starting out just two years ago, William Doyle has managed to build on previous trends, adding his own ideas to create a very new and unique sound, and even manages to sound like an old sage in the process.
So all in all I’m pretty excited to find out the winner tonight, but to a larger extent I’m excited for the future of music, especially if you consider the albums released recently that might have made the list, like Jessie Ware’s Tough Love or Thom Yorke’s Tomorrow’s Modern Boxes or even Johnny Marr’s Playland. It seems like music has acquired a new freedom in the modern age, with a multitude of artists vying to bring attention to the music that moves them.
Damon Albarn – Everyday Robots:
Albarn stands as sole representative of the old guard in 2014. Thom Yorke’s new album came out too late to be included, while other regularly tipped artists like PJ Harvey and Primal Scream have remained silent for the past few years. On Everyday Robots he remains as innovative as he ever was while criticising our increasing dependence on electronic devices.
Anna Calvi – One Breath:
Calvi’s second nomination after she got the nod in 2011 for her eponymous debut. Her music oozes a kind of intensity and self-assurance that can be frightening or entertaining and always a bit enervating. Maybe unsurprising that she has already joined the list of artists nominated for multiple prizes as she seems to be made in the likeness of PJ Harvey or, previously, Patti Smith.